Summary of ICMS Seminar Club presentation on Friday, November 26, 2021.
Title: Neuromelanins in brain aging and neurodegeneration
Speaker: Prof. Luigi Zecca, MD, Senior Researcher at the Institute of Biomedical Technologies-CNR, Milano, Italy
On Friday, November 26, by Zoom, Prof. Zecca gave a presentation to the ICMS Seminar Club of Fujita Health University. He presented a review on neuromelanin research and his groundbreaking discoveries in this field. The presentation, which we recorded, was of excellent didactic quality and is probably understandable from the level of graduate students.
For members of Fujita Health University, the recording is accessible at the “manabi” site :
ふじた学ばこ > 全体 > 研究支援 > 総合医科学研究所 >第3回 ICMS(総医研)セミナー・クラブ(59分)
Unfortunately, we cannot open the recording for a wider audience.
I enjoyed the presentation very much, as did Dr. Tomoyuki Murano, a young neuroscientist working at Fujita Health University, who summarized the presentation as “excellent.” There were 29 participants and, as always, there were many questions during the discussion section. The questions of the audience with answers by Prof. Zecca are shown at the end of this post. Because many aspects of neuromelanins are not fully sure yet, during the actual discussion I found it sometimes hard to grasp the contents, because resembling “questions within a question.” So, I am very grateful that Prof. Zecca took his time to carefully answer the questions again, now in written form, for the readers of this blog post.
The contents of the presentation
Because we recorded the event (see above), and I initially believed that we could make the recoring accessible to a wider audience, my below summary of the contents will only be brief in text. Most figures are screenshots from the recording and include the time indications so that readers (of our University) can easily find the relevant explanations in the recording. The summary does not include all the topics of Prof. Zecca’s presentation.
High concentrations of neuromelanin in the substantia nigra and locus coeruleus
Increasing in the elderly, macroscopically, dark pigments can be observed in the brain regions substantia nigra (SN; Latin for black substance) (Figs. 1 and 2) and locus coeruleus (LC; Latin for blue spot) (Figs. 3 and 4). These pigments are located in neurons that make a lot of neurotransmitter of the catecholamine category, namely dopamine in SN neurons and norepinephrine (also known as noradrenaline) in LC neurons. The pigments consist of neuromelanin structures, which, by the Zecca group, in less abundance and with a slightly different biochemistry have also been found in other brain regions, where they also increase with age (Fig. 5).
Degeneration of neuromelanin-containing neurons in Parkinson’s disease
Parkinson’s disease (PD) is mostly restricted to the elderly and concerns the progressive loss of dopamine-producing SN neurons and norepinephrine-producing LC neurons. These are the neuron populations with neuromelanin and therefore the SN and LC in PD patients are not as darkly colored as in healthy controls (Fig. 2; see also Fig. 24). Dopamine and norepinephrine produced by the SN and LC neurons are important for engaging in activities, so that PD patients have difficulties in initiating motor actions and suffer from a tendency for depression. The question is whether, in this story, neuromelanin plays protective or toxic roles, and Professor Zecca obtained evidence for both (see below).
What is neuromelanin?
Neuro stands for neurons and melanin (although there are multiple possible definitions) stands for dark biopolymer pigments of which the synthesis involves the oxidation of tyrosine or dopamine. Melanin production in the skin is a well-organized process, concerning the production of two different types of melanin polymers, named eumelanin and pheomelanin, in specialized organelles (melanosomes) that reside in specialized cells (melanocytes). In contrast, for understandable reasons, neuromelanin has long been considered as “cellular garbage” because of its amorphic shape, inert character, and association in vesicles together with proteins and lipids (Fig. 6). Professor Zecca and co-workers found that neuromelanin contains various metal ions amongst which iron (Figs. 7-to-9), and that—as they inferred from marker distribution—the vesicles are lysosomal in nature with an autophagosomal origin (Figs. 10-to-12). Biochemically, Professor Zecca and co-workers found that neuromelanin consists of eumelanin, pheomelanin, and dopamine-protein adducts, associated with metal ions (Fig. 12; see also the advertisement figure at the top of this blog post). The precise polymer constituents of neuromelanin, and the ratio of the different components of neuromelanin, can differ (e.g., per cell type) and keep being investigated (including by Profs. Shosuke Ito and Kazumasa Wakamatsu of Fujita Health University). Earlier this year, our seminar club had a presentation by Prof. Wakamatsu in which synthesis routes of eumelanin and pheomelanin were already discussed in some detail (see https://futamurayama-science.com/?p=301 for a simple summary). Prof. Zecca provided a convenient overview of how skin melanin is different from neuromelanin (Fig. 13). Prof. Zecca and his group also characterized the lipid contents of neuromelanin, showing the presence of glycerophospholipids and sphingolipids. (Fig. 14).
Accumulation of catecholamine induces neuromelanin production
For understanding the role of neuromelanin, it should first be known under which conditions neuromelanin is made. Prof. Zecca and co-workers established an elegant system that showed that neuromelanin production was induced by an excess of catecholamines. Namely, they could induce neuromelanin production in rat substantia nigra primary cell culture and PC12 (neuroblastic/eosinophilic) cell line by exposing them to L-DOPA (L-dihydroxyphenylalanine), which is rapidly converted to dopamine in the cytosol (Fig. 15). In accordance, if in such system the excess dopamine is discarded from the cytosol by transgenic overexpression of vesicular monoamine transporter-2 (VMAT2)—which sequesters dopamine into synaptic vesicles—, neuromelanin production is no longer induced (summarized in Fig. 16).
The protective role of neuromelanin
Prof. Zecca obtained evidence that neuromelanin has both protective and a toxic roles (summarized in Fig. 17). Neuromelanins are protective by aggregating toxic agents into inert complexes. Among these toxic (when in excess) substances are catecholamines, iron and other metals, which all may contribute to oxidative damage, and a variety of other compounds. Brain iron accumulates in aging, and the increase of neuromelanin helps to remove excess of reactive iron. Prof. Zecca and co-workers found that neuromelanin, or its melanin component as represented by synthetic melanin generated from dopamine, has an anti-oxidative effect, as shown by these agents reducing the production of hydroxyl radicals if added to a Fenton’s reaction sample containing iron, hydrogen peroxide, and salicylic acid (Fig. 18).
The toxic role of neuromelanin
In the substantia nigra of Parkinson’s disease patients, extracellular neuromelanin of degenerated dopaminergic neurons can be found and activated microglia accumulate around the degenerating/degenerated neurons (Fig. 19, in which Prof. Zecca kindly shows micrographs from work of Prof. Toshiharu Nagatsu of Fujita Health University). Prof. Zecca and co-workers found that isolated neuromelanin activates microglia (brain immune cells) which then migrate towards it and digest it (Fig. 20). Moreover, they found that activation by neuromelanin induces microglia to kill neurons, both in vitro and in vivo (Fig. 21). Prof. Zecca has proposed that the stimulation of microglia through neuromelanin released by dying neurons establishes a vicious cycle of neuroinflammation and neurodegeneration (Fig. 22).
Prof. Zecca and co-workers also found that neuromelanin-containing neurons express MHC class I, and that CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) can be associated with these neurons (Fig. 23). They proposed that the MHC class I restricted recognition by CTLs is one of the mechanisms by which neuromelanin containing neurons are killed in Parkinson’s disease (Fig. 24).
Measuring neuromelanin abundance (as a representative of PD progression) by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
Already in 2002, Prof. Zecca and co-workers proposed to use the loss of neuromelanin in Parkinson’s disease (PD) as a diagnostic parameter to be measured by magnetic resonance imaging techniques. This made sense, because neuromelanin includes a high concentration of iron, and because in Parkinson’s disease patients there is a 30-80% decrease of neuromelanin. A few years later, another research group established MRI analysis indeed, and nowadays MRI can be used to estimate the level of neuromelanin and thus of PD disease progression in the substantia nigra and locus coeruleus (Figs. 24-27). This system can be used to confirm diagnosis and evaluate the progression of PD. This method has not been sufficiently fine-tuned yet for pre-symptomatic diagnosis of PD, but Prof. Zecca has good hope that—in the near future—it may.
Collaborations
Professor Zecca kindly thanked his collaborators that contributed to the data shown in his presentation, among which Professors Shosuke Ito and Kazumasa Wakamatsu of Fujita Health University (Fig. 28).
Questions by the audience
(These are the questions and answers that I remember. They are modified for clarity)
Question 1.
Neuromelanins in the substantia nigra and locus coeruleus are produced from dopamine and norepinephrine, respectively. These neurotransmitters are related to feelings of excitement (dopamine) and activity/anxiety (norepinephrine), which, at least for the excitement and activity parts, are lower in elderly people. So why then do elderly people have more neuromelanin? Do they produce more dopamine and/or epinephrine, or is it less efficiently secreted? If the latter is true, could excess neuromelanin production be halted if people would keep doing exciting things?
Answer: Neuromelanin is continuously synthesized and accumulated during the life and its turnover is very slow. Then neuronal content of neuromelanine remains high although catecholamine levels decrease in aging. In psychosis typically present in schizophrenia there is an increased activity of dopamine system. The psychosis are conrolled by drugs, psychological therapies, and social support.
Question 2.
For Parkinson’s disease (PD) you mentioned an inflamed situation with activated mircoglia that contribute to neurotoxicity. How can you be sure that the neurons did not die in a more controlled fashion, namely by apoptosis, with the microglia just playing a role in that apoptosis and/or in clearing the cellular debris?
Answer: Neurons can obviously die by apoptosis, autommune mechanism and others. After neuronal death microglia can work to clean up cellular debris.
Question 3.
Research shows that people with PD have a higher risk of developing melanoma, and people with melanoma have a higher risk of developing PD [e.g., see https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6130416/pdf/jpd-8-jpd171263.pdf]. Do you think that treatment with L-Dopa [the precursor of dopamine which can transfer the blood-brain barrier and is used as a drug to increase dopamine concentrations], which is a common treatment in PD, can inadvertently promote melanoma?
Answer: As far as I know no one of the drugs to treat PD (L-DOPA, dopamine agonistst and others) is suspected to promote or increase the risk for melanoma.
Question 4.
You mentioned that dopaminergic neurons with neuromelanin express MHC class I molecules that present peptides at the cell surface that stimulate cytotoxic T cells. Which peptides do you think are involved?
Answer: We have shown in cultures that peptides derived from ovalbumin can be presented by MHC-I on neuronal membranes so that neurons are targeted by CD8+ Lymphocytes. These peptides in human brain can be of any type and generated by proteolytic processing of proteins in neurons or other cells, then the peptides are loaded on MHC-I inside neurons and presented on membrane.
Question 5.
Do you think that dopaminergic neurons possess tyrosinase?
Answer: It was demonstrated by our group and others with different methods including LC-MS that dopaminergic neurons do not have tyrosinase
Question 6.
Do you think that melanocytes possess tyrosine hydroxylase?
Answer: Yes indeed tyrosine hydroxylase was reported to be present in human melanosomes
Question 7.
Do other neurons besides catecholaminergic neurons also possess neuromelanin?
Answer: Yes we have shown that neuromelanine occurs also in brain regions without catecholaminergic neurons. In fact phenolic precursors like modified catechols different than dopamine and noradrenaline can be oxidized to generate melanic compounds.
Question 8.
Does neuromelanin accumulation inhibit tyrosine hydroxylase activity?
Answer: I think neuromelanin accumulation does not inhibit tyrosine hydroxylase activity. In fact you can see neurons having high neuromelanin and that highly express tyrosine hydroxylase.
Question 9.
Why does neuromelanin not degrade like skin melanin [which consists of eumelanin and pheomelanin]?
Answer: Neuromelanin is a complex compound containing melanic, lipid and peptide component. It is insoluble and highly stable in brain tissue and in isolated form. It is very different from skin melanin. Autolysosomal organelles containing neuromelanin are different fom melanosomes and are very stable.
Question 10.
Can the amount of neuromelanin be used as a marker for the progression of PD?
Answer: Yes, we have shown that neuromelanin concentration decreases during PD and this decrease can be imaged by MRI to diagnose PD.
Question 11.
Why does treatment with L-Dopa not increase the amount of neuromelanin?
Answer:There are not conclusive data but in principle it is possible that in PD patients the L-Dopa treatment increases the content of neuromelanine in the spared neurons.
Question 12.
There appears to be a switch from neuromelanins being protective to neuromelanins being toxic. Can you elaborate on the nature of that switch?
Answer: Extraneuronal neuromelanins are always toxic since they activate mcroglia and induce neurodegeneration. Intraneuronally the synthesis of neuromelanins is protective as it removes excess cytosolic catechols non accumulated in synaptic vesicles, which would cause toxicity. However intraneuronally an autoimmune mecahnisn of neurodegeneration may occur through the loading of foreign peptides on MHC-I and presentation on neuronal membranes, then neurons would be attacked by CD8+ cell.
Question 13.
Why is PD negatively associated with the risk of many cancers (with the exception of melanoma) [e.g., see https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnagi.2020.00060/full]?
Answer: This relationship seemed clear in the past. However it has become more controversial recently with epidemiology studies reporting contradictory results, as many variables are present and some are not controlled. Even the few experimental studies did not show consistent results.
Question 14.
The model seems to say that increased iron concentrations in the brains of the elderly promote neuromelanin formation and thereby induce neuron mortality. Can’t people change these iron concentrations by changing their diet?
Answer: The involvement of iron in neuromelanin synthesis is a phenomenon starting early in life. During aging total iron (mainly built by ferritins) in substantia nigra accumulates. The iron bound to neuromelanin is non toxic. The reactive/toxic iron is present in hemosiderin and accumulates in aging. The iron metabolism in brain and the accumulation of reactive iron are independent from peripheral and blood iron, then diet does not significantly affect brain iron.